Last week I read an article in The Guardian online by Madeleine Bunting: “Why we will come to see Mindfulness as mandatory” and you can read it here: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/06/mindfulness-hospitals-schools. I thought it was a masterful piece, covering the history, practice and application of mindfulness in every aspect of our lives.
Then I read on down through the comments from readers. There were some supportive comments about how helpful some people are finding mindfulness practice and some examples of practices. Then there were the cynical and plain anti-mindfulness comments; from there being a risk of using it in a negative way to incite anti-social behaviour to the view that it just doesn’t work. Making an effort to suspend my knee-jerk reactions to be a) dismissive of and irritated by the anti-mindfulness lobby, and b) to start questioning whether mindfulness is really of value in the modern world and will be a ‘passing fad’; I pondered on some of the objections, which I paraphrase below….
Mindfulness doesn’t work or it would have been widely adopted already
I can absolutely understand the argument. My take on it is that, it isn’t a ‘quick fix’, it takes practice and willpower to stick with it. Modern society hasn’t been very good at giving things time along with the encouragement, support, and challenge that it takes to keep up the practice. Our systems and procedures are not designed for it – in the case of health services courses of treatment may be limited to 6 weeks, for instance, seeing one practitioner and nothing in between appointments; in the case of business, our industrial models of command and control, strength valued as a leadership style, and people taking on machine-like functions, are still in evidence. Humanity is only starting to be valued in organisations. We are seeing the digital, social media, and hi-tech companies leading and embracing new ways of working that do value self-awareness (e.g. Google has a Head of Mindfulness) , collective working, and more democratic ways of organising. It seems to me that mindfulness practice is also immensely flexible in that practice can be adapted to suit the context and the people. What is most important is that it is taught by experienced and well qualified people. This is not a ‘band-wagon’ to be jumped on. The Google Head of Mindfulness says that teachers should have 2000 hours of practice under their belts. On this note, I am full of anticipation about working with Dr Joel and Michelle Levey next month – they have worked with some many of those organisations introducing mindfulness into workplaces, pioneering practices that support each organisation’s mission along with a strong ethical underlay and a long lifetime’s experience between them. More later…..
My conclusion is: give it time and keep an open mind; it will not cure all ills but it will be part of the remedy for many of them.
It would be a bad thing if the Government made it mandatory – a bit like brain washing or 1984.
Making Mindfulness mandatory certainly goes against the grain for me. Making it available and accessible to everyone in a way that helps them find the techniques that suit their circumstances and preferences is, however, what I would advocate. And, of course, Madeleine Bunting’s article is not advocating that Government should make it mandatory – notwithstanding the launch of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Mindfulness that sparked her article. Through practising and realising the benefits individually and, just as importantly, collectively we will make our own decisions to ‘make it mandatory’ for ourselves. Like anything, it can be used for good or ill and the vital element that makes it such a potentially powerful way of being, is the commitment that needs to be made to a strong ethical value-set that is the foundation of the practice. There is much to be explored in the collective practice of mindfulness and the events which I am anticipating with The Leveys in June will include some work by my colleague, George Pòr. George is leading the exploration of collective mindfulness, how it manifests and how we might achieve it more. More of that later….
My conclusion is: mindfulness must be taught by people who are well trained themselves, we must do this well so we can be well individually and as communities and society. It has the potential to become mandatory in that we each, individually, elect to make it mandatory ourselves, because the benefits for us individually and collectively will bring reward and fulfilment.
People should not profit from mindfulness – it is from the Buddhist tradition and buddhists teach it for little or no cost.
Well, now here’s a thing. I do understand the objection to profit-making organisations trying to cash in on something that is popularly trending. I was very struck by a comment made in an interview by Thich Nhat Hanh (known as Thay), one of the most admired and respected mindfulness teachers alive today, when he was asked about the motives of people teaching mindfulness: the interviewer said Thay’s response was: “as long as business leaders practice “true” mindfulness, it does not matter if the original intention is triggered by wanting to be more effective at work or to make bigger profits. That is because the practice will fundamentally change their perspective on life as it naturally opens hearts to greater compassion and develops the desire to end the suffering of others.”
In which case, as long as those who are offering to train are themselves practising “true” mindfulness does it matter if one of their intentions is to earn a good living?
Also, it is strange that people will often value something more because it comes with a price tag. When I did some sales training recently, the trainers were encouraging us to put up our fees and prices because if we under-valued ourselves and our services, we would not attract clients. So we may, in fact, be able to spread the practice to some people who would otherwise not see its value. Mad but seemingly true! As with most things in life, giving choice is what is important.
Later…
So I am not apologetic when an organisation that I work for is offering mindfulness workshops, aimed at leaders of organisations, as well as anyone interested to find out more, at a fee. You can find out more about Future Considerations, who is partnering with CollectiveIntelligence to organise them, here: http://futureconsiderations.com/who/about/.
You can register for the workshops here: http://www.eventbrite.co.uk/o/future-considerations-and-communityintelligence-ltd-6375007851?s=23745133
You can join a Facebook group called Mindful Together and join the conversation here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/mindfultogether/